Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Chocolate cookie repeat...

There is a cookie recipe that we made way back in 2005, shortly after we started this website, that we have sent to friends and family, made for neighbors and prepared for a few bake sales over the years since then. What we haven't done was make them again for the Weekly Wednesday Treat Day!

I was thinking about this the other day and mentioned those Peanut Butter Filled Chocolate Cookies to Jeff - he suggested that we skip a new recipe this week and get these into the oven as soon as possible. Because we both even liked the picture we took way back then, I gave the camera a break this week too!

What I did do was tool around with the recipe we had posted - no differences in the ingredients really, but I wanted to update it to how I write out recipes now. I honestly don't have much else to say that I haven't already said when we first talked about these, other than these cookies are still just as exceptional as when we first tried them out - if you haven't made them yourself, what are you waiting for?


  1. Ever since you first posted those, they have been one of my all time fav cookie recipes! I used to bring them into my office and they always got rave reviews. Thanks!

  2. Has it really been that long ago since you first posted these? They have become a staple here since then. My DS loves them and ranks them as his number two cookie behind Snickerdoodles.

    Time sure does fly!

  3. Hi, My name is Rachel:
    I really love your blog, I'll be trying out your recipes in the near future.
    I was wondering if you'd like to do a link exchange.
    here's my site:

    thank you for your time
    Rachel Neil

  4. I have made them quite frequently and they are always requested...love, love, love them!!

  5. Lauren - I definitely need to make them more often!

    Erika - I thought the same thing when I looked back to when we first made them. Crazy!

    Rachel - Thanks for finding us!

    Anon - Good to hear! Thanks for the feedback.

  6. My kids love this cookie and them always asking me to bake some of this for their afternoon snacks. I guess I should try to freeze this dough so that every time they ask me to bake some of this I just need to cut the dough then bake it instantly. What do you think?

  7. Rose - I haven't tried freezing the raw dough, but we froze some of the baked cookies from this last batch and they were just as good thawed!